• About Us
    • Staff & Friends
    • Action & Events
    • Gifts
    • FAQ
  • Join Us
  • Journal
  • Chaparral
    • Chaparral Types
    • Old Growth Chaparral
    • Chaparral Biome?
    • Species
    • Myths
    • Vernal Pools
    • Grizzly Bear National Monument
    • Rancho Guejito
    • Chap Preservation Plan
  • Geology
    • Where to Start
    • Geology Primer
    • San Diego Geology
    • Serpentine Chaparral
    • Manzanita Geology
    • Watersheds
  • Education
    • Videos
    • Publications
    • The Chaparralian
    • Writing
    • Wildness Within
    • Trail and Classroom
  • Threats
    • Cal Fire
    • Fire Suppression Fallacy
    • Too Much Fire
    • "Fuel" Treatments
    • Prescribed Fire
    • Climate Change
    • Cuyamaca State Park
    • San Diego County
  • Fire
    • Chaparral Fire Ecology
    • It's About the Wind
    • Protecting Your Home
    • Forest Fires
    • Dead Trees?
    • Native Americans
    • Dear Governor Newsom
    • Fire Prevention Services

The Fire Suppression Fallacy

How Agencies Justify the Destruction of Habitat with Chainsaws, Grinding Machines, and Herbicides

The Beginning of the Fire Suppression Fallacy

How did the observation that fire suppression has caused some forests to miss several natural fire cycles metastasize into a pernicious stereotype that has convinced huge numbers of people that Nature is sick, clogged with dead trees and unhealthy vegetation, and is ready to vaporize in the next wildfire?
As is the case with fear-mongering media outlets, catastrophizing even the most insignificant events to obtain attention, images and situations are cherry-picked by proponents of the fire suppression fallacy to communicate the most dire circumstance. The propaganda has been incredibly successful, convincing politicians to allocate billions of dollars to “fix” Nature with grinding machines, chainsaws, and herbicide.
As with most stories designed to panic, the truth becomes embellished and inconvenient facts are ignored or forgotten. The origins of the fire suppression fallacy can be traced back to
the late 1800’s when westward expansion brought more human beings, and hence sources of ignition, into a highly flammable environment. Vast piles of logging slash (limbs and other waste from timber operations), hot cinders from trains traveling deep into the back country, unattended fires utilized to clear land, outright carelessness (Pyne 1982), and most importantly drought and high winds, all played a role in adding more, larger fires to the landscape. Between 1865 and 1910 large wildfires from the Great Lakes region to California led federal and state governments to form cooperative firefighting agreements and pass regulations attempting to reduce the likelihood of human caused ignitions and fight fires when they started. Many of these fires, such as the 1871 Peshtigo fire in Wisconsin, which killed an estimated 1,500 people, were linked to piles of logging slash... Continue reading here on our online journal, Chaparral Wisdom.

The Techniques Used to "Fix" Nature

Old-growth manzanita chaparral masticated. San Bernardino National Forest.
Chainsaws and livestock. Stanislaus National Forest.
Ceanothus sprayed with herbicide. Rancho Cuyamaca State Park.
Please listen to this special podcast with Roy Ben-Tzvi This interview provides an excellent overview of all things chaparral including what we do, what chaparral is, the best way to deal with wildfire risk, and the role Nature can play to create better lives and a more positive society.

Video can’t be displayed

This video is not available.

Contact
EMAIL: nature at californiachaparral.org FAQ
California Chaparral Institute P.O. Box 545 Escondido, CA 92033
SITE MAP
Regain control of your time and your humanity. Think, create for yourself. Visit Nature with friends.
ABOUT US FAQ JOIN US JOURNAL CHAPARRAL EDUCATION THREATS FIRE

We use cookies to enable essential functionality on our website, and analyze website traffic. By clicking Accept you consent to our use of cookies. Read about how we use cookies.

Your Cookie Settings

We use cookies to enable essential functionality on our website, and analyze website traffic. Read about how we use cookies.

Cookie Categories
Essential

These cookies are strictly necessary to provide you with services available through our websites. You cannot refuse these cookies without impacting how our websites function. You can block or delete them by changing your browser settings, as described under the heading "Managing cookies" in the Privacy and Cookies Policy.

Analytics

These cookies collect information that is used in aggregate form to help us understand how our websites are being used or how effective our marketing campaigns are.